

Well, if we wanna still have voting actions federate between instances and different services (meaning everyone can see the total vote counts, not just the votes given by users on single instance), that information has to be publicly sent to other instances. Like I said, I believe there have been some discussions about ways to anonymize outgoing voting actions, but I imagine there would be quite a few issues to think about. For instance, doing so would probably make it much easier for bad actors to send bogus votes.
The difference of opinion is that Lemmy’s devs believe that services receiving voting data from Lemmy shouldn’t publicly display individual votes, but only the aggregate counts (just like Lemmy itself does). Many others, myself included, think this approach creates a false sense of privacy, potentially leading some users to believe that their votes are private when they actually aren’t, especially given that services like Lemvotes exist.



Hmm, by next version you mean the upcoming 1.0.0 release? They have implemented private communities but I haven’t seen vote privacy mentioned anywhere. Can you link some source for this?