Decompilation is a legal gray area. The Super Mario 64 decompilation is CC0, and I’m not aware of Nintendo pursuing any
legal action against the decompilation itself.
Isnt the case with the decompilation projects, is that what they give you are the tools that will do the decompilation, rather than the decompilation result?
the tools fall under the copyright of the tools authors, where as the decompilation result very much still falls under nintendo. So they are fine distributing the former and not the latter
Super Mario 64 decomp includes decompiled C code. What makes it legal is that it only includes the reverse engineered code, but no assets (like textures, sound, 3D models). The code itself is useless without the original ROMs.
It is in general mainly a gray area because of copyright. Possibly also DCMA and patents. But in the general case, if it is LLM-generated, there is no copyright.
Companies still might try to sue, but for some areas like planned-obsolete hardware, that might not be worth it.
Proprietary code is rarely shared to the public. An enforced Creative Commons license won’t do much on this regard.
But it can be decompiled now. If the source code bears no copyright, the decompiled code won’t either.
Decompilation is a legal gray area. The Super Mario 64 decompilation is CC0, and I’m not aware of Nintendo pursuing any legal action against the decompilation itself.
Isnt the case with the decompilation projects, is that what they give you are the tools that will do the decompilation, rather than the decompilation result?
the tools fall under the copyright of the tools authors, where as the decompilation result very much still falls under nintendo. So they are fine distributing the former and not the latter
Super Mario 64 decomp includes decompiled C code. What makes it legal is that it only includes the reverse engineered code, but no assets (like textures, sound, 3D models). The code itself is useless without the original ROMs.
https://github.com/n64decomp/sm64
It is in general mainly a gray area because of copyright. Possibly also DCMA and patents. But in the general case, if it is LLM-generated, there is no copyright. Companies still might try to sue, but for some areas like planned-obsolete hardware, that might not be worth it.